Quote of the week...please share your favourite line from Ayn Rand's writings

“Happiness is that state of consciousness which proceeds from the achievement of one's values.”

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

Creating a Just Society

I have firmly believed that if there is anything that a man should concern himself with the affairs of another, then it should be with regards to seeking of justice for his fellow human beings. There is nothing altruist about this. On the contrary it is of utmost self interest of the one fighting for others justice as this is core building block for creating or maintaining a civilised society, which off-course is in the interest of every man other than the criminal himself.

It is in this context that I see the spate of recent protests, supposedly by the ordinary citizens as a matter of great pride. Regretably, it has been largely a emotion filled ranting for justice. While it does pressurise the State to act swiftly than it would have done otherwise in the specific case of the rape of a women in Delhi, does little to bring in a lasting change. Lasting change cannot be brought in by people without the necessary intellectual ammunition which I have scarcely seen being offered by anyone\anywhere. I would like to believe that if there is any body who can offer it, it is us and therefore I put forth the below for discussion\debate.

I am calling this the "Five things to be changed" only because I found these to be the most important. Changes in the constitution in itself can be all encompassing. Secondly, there can be more than 5, but this is the first five. I am not elaborating, certainly not beyond the basic outlines of each of the actions hoping to leave that to the room for discussion.

  1. Re-write the constitution.  This is the most important of all changes required. Our constitution has given too much room for the government to digress and as a result has spread itself too thin to be able to deliver where it needs to. Moreover, like Hayek said, the kind of all encompassing socialist state that we have only results in progressively corrupting the society itself and eventually to a situation where the worst of the society comes to lead it to eventual ruin. The founding principle if the constitution will be to enshrine the rights of man and protection of these rights. The constitution will have to ensure that the smallest of the minorities are protected of their rights and that their rights will not be legislated away by the majority.
  2. We do not need our representatives to pass laws which then we all then need to follow. The legislature can be completely abolished or can act a representative group that proposes laws, which then will be approved or rejected by the people again through direct action through national referendum. A more suitable alternative is to ensure that the people themselves pass all new laws through national referendum.
  3. Close all government departments except the ones dealing with in protecting the constitutional rights and delivering Justice – Courts, Police & the Army. Move the Government personal from the abolished departments to the courts & police etc. The government will divest all its interests in business and solely focus on its mandate of Law & order and Justice. The government will there fore consists of A) Judiciary B) Police and Armed Forces and C)Administration. The reason for calling the 3rd estate as Administration is to emphasis that it will not have any executive functions and will act purely as an administrator within the strict oversight of the people.
  4. The Chiefs of Police of each police districts and his\her deputies and the attorneys will be directly elected by the people\residents of that district, including fixing of their compensation and will be answerable to the people.
  5. Taxes will be constitutionally limited, the government will have no right or authority to levy taxes\change the tax rates. Every citizen of the country should be required to pay taxes, not marginal taxation and no tax exemption. Government will be prohibited from Borrowing funds or creating any future liability on its assets or incomes. The central bank and all such government monopolies will have to go. The government will not pass on their rights to private hands – essentially there will be no private or government monopolies or charters.


  1. Excellent points, Yousouf!

    "I would like to believe that if there is any body who can offer it, it is us"

    Having a more active Objectivist/Libertarian blog would help - which I hoped this one would turn out to be. I confess my own guilt in this regard.

    Have a happy and hopefully a freer new year everybody.

  2. You raise some interesting discussions Yousuf, well written! Definitely lots to think about...

  3. Why the hell is not Atlas Shrugged neither The Fountainhead published in Hindi? What are you people doing??? Those young ones who really feel the poverty in their guts ARE looking for answers, but not for too long. Capitalism can ONLY save this fast deteriorating country, or any other for that matter, but NO ONE on earth explains Capitalism better than this Russian born truly American author. Bring Ayn Rand in Hindi and see a revolution like never before unfold! DO IT!!

  4. Din't know that Ayn Rand's works are not available in Hindi, its a good suggestion.

  5. hi there . . im happy to see some indian objectivists. For such discussions on governance pls visit sabhlokcity.com.

    From the above points i think some are just outpour of emotions.

    I would like to form a group of all such ayn rand fans and hold meetups and spread her ideas etc. .i think we can start with fb . .pls reply to this comment . .also i think the basic entry shud be for those who have read atlas shrugged. I want to make this huge as to affect policy making but thts for later lets start small now.
    add me on fb: www.facebook.com/allwynm