Quote of the week...please share your favourite line from Ayn Rand's writings
“Happiness is that state of consciousness which proceeds from the achievement of one's values.”
Tell us about your journey...
Monday, November 9, 2009
How Socialism works
Friday, November 6, 2009
Should the state have a claim on the dead?
The detailed discussion, and the various arguments can be read at the thread "Estate tax under objectivism", in the eGroup. If you are not a member, you are welcome to join the eGroup, the goal is to discuss the implications and impact of Ayn Rand's ideas in today's world.
Wednesday, November 4, 2009
Ayn Rand on the cover of the Reason magazine
And on the cover of the latest issue!-
I don't think I have missed any.All Reason covers are here.
What got me going was this Che like graphic of Ayn Rand posted by Ed Driscoll according to whom it's "a reprint of one of Reason’s 1973-era covers featuring a posterized version of Ayn Rand".
However I couldn't find any such cover.
I do however agree with one the commentators to that post that it would make a great T-shirt!
The 1942 film of 'We the Living' is now out on DVD
Big Hollywood has a review-
We The Living was made during World War II in Mussolini’s Italy, of all places. The government warily allowed it to be filmed as a propaganda vehicle against the Soviet Union. But when Mussolini realized the movie was a critique not only of communism but of all forms of statism, he banned it from theatres, where it was a smash hit.
The government rounded up and destroyed all copies of the film – save one, the original negative, which was secreted away. As we are informed by the fascinating documentary (included among the DVD extras), the film’s reels languished unseen for decades until Rand’s attorneys went hunting for it among the Italian film community.
Duncan Scott, who produced the DVD release, explains how as a young editor he talked his way into recutting and subtitling the film alongside Ayn Rand herself. WTL had originally been released as two separate films. They combined them, trimmed away some of the excess, and removed or redubbed pro-fascist propaganda speeches inserted at the insistence of the authorities.
The issue of re-dubbing is intriguing -
Scott tells how in the original version, Andrei delivered a heated diatribe against the evils of capitalism. Needless to say, this speech didn’t exactly belong. Not content merely to change the subtitles, Scott actually hired a sound-a-like Italian actor so he could redub the voice track in Italian to match the new subtitles.
Unfortunately the digital transfer was done in 1987, and the cost of a high-definition remastering was prohibitive for this DVD release, so the picture quality isn’t quite as crisp as one might wish. Nevertheless, it is completely watchable.
Glenn Kenny quotes J.Hoberman's description of the film -
"Shot mainly in close-up and entirely in the studio, We the Living evokes an atmosphere of total, demoralized corruption. As directed by...Alessandrini, a filmmaker with some Hollywood experience, the movie does not lack for mise-en-scéne. The grim sets are scrawled with hammer-and-sickle graffiti and Cyrillic exhortations, emblazoned with menacing posters of proletarian ape-men and encephalitic Lenins. That everyone is always layered with clothing adds to the sense of unpleasant crowding, just as the already high fog quotient is significantly augmented by a constant sucking on cigarettes. The atmosphere is as gray as the dialogue is purple."
If anybody gets a hand on the DVD, you know where to contact me.
(cross posted at the Liberty News Central)
Monday, November 2, 2009
Ayn Rand on Pop Quiz
Ayn Rand has always topped popularity charts. Her novels that expound her unique brand of individualism still hold readers in awe. Heading the list of course is Fountainhead —story of an enigmatic architect named Howard Roark. In India, Ayn Rand has a loyal following from college students to film stars. Find out more about Ayn Rand and her works.
QUESTIONS
1. Atlas Shrugged and Fountainhead by Ayn Rand is dedicated to Frank OConnor. Who is Frank OConnor?Please visit the Sunday on Mail, Pop Quiz, for the answers, if you need help!
2. Ayn Rands novels all propounded her pet philosophy — that of rational self- interest, a morality that stood in compete opposition to the accepted political, social and religious attitude. What is her unique philosophy called?
3. Which novel of hers is set in Soviet Russia and portrays the impact of Russian revolution on three people who demand the right to live their own lives?
4. Fraternity 9- 3452, Democracy 4- 6998, Unanimity 7- 3304, Collective 1- 5537, International 1- 5537 are all characters in which novel of Ayn Rand?
5. Fountainhead has four chapters. The last chapter is named after the chief protagonist Howard Roark. What are the other chapters called?
6. The undercurrent of Fountainhead is a violent love affair between Howard Roark and an exceedingly beautiful lady who loved and yet struggled to defeat him. Simple — name the lady.
7. Howard Roark completed only three years of his architecture course before he was expelled. Which A- School did Howard go to?
8. Atlas Shrugged is divided into three parts — first part is called Non Contradiction, second part is called Either- or. What is the third part called?
9. Ayn Rand achieved Broadway success with which play of hers?
10. Ayn Rand and Bollywood. Yes, The Night of January 16th has inspired a 1989 Bollywood movie starring Zeenat Aman and Ashutosh Gowariker. Name the movie.
Friday, October 30, 2009
An informal report on the 4th Atlas Meet - Delhi
Tuesday, October 20, 2009
"Howard Roark in New Delhi"
Thursday, October 15, 2009
The 4th Monthly Atlas Meet, Delhi
The monthly Atlas Meet in Delhi will take place, as usual, on the fourth Saturday of October, that is on the 24th of October. Please mark your diaries.
Monday, October 12, 2009
Music and Movie 'Sharing': A Lesser Crime?
The sharing of music and movie files by means of illegal downloading and copying is as serious a problem in
In a very clearly written article titled ‘It’s Not Stealing Because I don’t want it to be’ (click on this title to read it), Objectivist writer Rituparna Basu evaluates the psychology of music theft, including how people rationalize it, and explains exactly why it is wrong. There is also an interesting discussion that follows the article, in the comments column. I think, at the end of the day, all it takes is for people to recognize and remember that unscrupulous movie and music sharing is a crime equivalent to theft. Before endorsing any source, they also should not evade the moral responsibility to find out exactly what channels of movie and music sharing are legal, i.e., done with the consent of the original owners of the content, and what are illegal. In fact, this was the kind of realization that helped me, an erstwhile thief, improve my ways.
I’ll use this opportunity to mention that Rituparna Basu was the 2007 winner of The Fountainhead essay contest for high school students. She writes regularly for The Undercurrent. Click here to read more articles written by her.
The Best Reason To Read Atlas Shrugged
Objectivists and admirers of Ayn Rand’s fiction realize that there couldn’t be a better time or a more urgent need to advocate Atlas Shrugged to new readers. The novel is being promoted and talked about everywhere. In the same vein, I read a piece in an American Objectivist campus magazine, The Undercurrent, titled ‘The Value of Atlas Shrugged’. It is a well-written piece, and gives a fairly good introduction to the philosophical foundations of the novel, and what makes it so unique. However, while it suggests exactly why the novel is so pertinent in the current crisis, there is a missing element in that introduction, as there is in most of the current publicity campaign – a very important missing element.
And that is, a fair treatment of the story. When a novel is presented to new readers, it is generally done so by means of a snapshot of the plot and the characters. It is implicitly understood that the primary reason why someone should pick up a story is because they are intrigued by it. Ayn Rand herself would probably not have liked someone to read Atlas just because it has crucial economic and philosophical lessons to offer, which have changed the lives of so many people, and are immediately relevant. These could be powerful motivating factors, but she would have wanted people to read it, first and foremost, for the pleasure of the story. Of course, the immense knowledge that the novel demonstrates must be mentioned, but it is not meant to be a treatise. That is not how it is written, and that is not the impression that should be conveyed to potential readership. This does not mean that one must go into a detailed elaboration of the plot, but certainly a clear mention of what makes it so exciting is called for, especially since Atlas Shrugged has such an original and spell-binding plot, and such dramatic characterization!
As far as the article in The Undercurrent is concerned, it seems to suggest that the plot of the story revolves around a corporate battle, with barons of industry and science fighting against an antagonistic corporate landscape. There is no mention of the fact that it is a mystery story about an unknown man, operating in secrecy (John Galt), who is trying to stop the motor of the world, and a woman (Dagny Taggart) trying desperately to discover his identity and defeat him. As one by one, the greatest men and women of
When any objectivist advocates the novel, whatever the time and space they use for it, they must seek to advocate it in its entirety. And that means, conveying not only the value that the story offers, but also the idea of the story itself.
Click here to access the fall 2009 edition of The Undercurrent, which contains the article. In spite of the limitations of this article, it deems mention that The Undercurrent publishes some excellent analyses of the current political and cultural scenario in
Saturday, October 10, 2009
"The Night of January 16th" - YouTube Video
Ayn Rand Institute thrives despite recession

A news website in Orange County, California, has an article featuring the amazing success of the ARI, which is based in Irvine. It reports that
"The Ayn Rand Institute, the largest of the Rand think tanks and perhaps Orange County’s most eclectic nonprofit (because how many nonprofits dedicated to profit arethere, really?), has seen revenues shoot up26 percent over the past three years (to$6.3 million), while net assets jumped 30 percent (to $1.3 million).
“And we might have our best year ever this year,” said a clearly-pleased Yaron Brook, the foundation’s president.
Why? “Something is going on,” he said. “People are frustrated. They don’t like what this administration is doing, they want answers, and she is viewed as having answers. The result is people are willing to write checks right now. It’s viewed as an antidote to where the culture is heading.”"
The full article is available here and makes for some very interesting reading.
A related article traces the origins and personal history of Yaron Brook, ARI's charismatic president, whose leadership has seen the foundation grow to more than three times its size from when he took over the reigns in 2000. It asks and answers the question
"How did Yaron Brook (brought up as a socialist in a Kibbutz in Israel) come to be one of the nation's – nay, the world's – leading spokesmen for "rational selfishness" and "laissez-faire capitalism"?"
The full article is available here
Monday, October 5, 2009
Tara and Govind: The first couple of Objectivism in India
Together the Malkanis hosted the Ayn Rand Club in Bombay for over thirty years. Over the years, they had collected almost every book, cassettes or video tapes by or on Ayn Rand, and objectivism.
I came to know the Malkanis in the mid 1980s. And for a few years in the late 1980s, she lent out the tapes from her collection, lectures of Ayn Rand, and others, for us and others to listen in over six cities across India. Many friendships were established at these clubs have continued till today.
It would be great to hear from those of you who had known the Malkanis personally, or had known about them. Some of my additional comments can be read on our website here.
Saturday, October 3, 2009
Frank Lloyd Wright sketched a home for Ayn Rand
On display, at an exhibition on "Drawings and Objects by Architects," currently being held in Los Angeles, is "a preliminary rendering of a "cottage studio," in colored pencil on paper, that the legendary architect crafted for Rand". The cottage was never built.
"Cottage studio" is an unlikely term for an imposing, cantilevered building with horizontal bands of fieldstone. Asymmetric terraces of concrete or stucco radiate off a vertical spine, perhaps a chimney, and seem to float on ribbons of clerestory windows.Please read the complete article "Frank Lloyd Wright sketch on exhibit" by Martha Groves, in the Los Angeles Times, on 3 Oct. 2009.
With expressive gestures, Wright suggests cascading vines and fountains to soften the composition of hard materials. A writing studio was to be placed at the top of the tower with louvered windows to capture light, ocean views and air. Rand (1905-82) expressed her delight in an October 1946 letter to Wright:
"The house you designed for me is magnificent. I gasped when I saw it. It is the particular kind of sculpture in space which I love and which nobody but you has ever been able to achieve.
In "The Fountainhead," modern architecture provided a convenient vehicle for her views. In her 1937 letter, she told Wright that her new novel "is to be the story of an architect who follows his own convictions throughout his life, no matter what society thinks of it or does to him. . . . A man who has an ideal and goes through hell for it. So you can understand why it seems to me that of all men on earth you are the one I must see."
But she added: "My hero is not you. I do not intend to follow in the novel the events of your life and career. His life will not be yours, nor his work, perhaps not even his artistic ideals. But his spirit is yours -- I think."
The letter is one of hundreds in the posthumous 1995 collection "Letters of Ayn Rand" edited by Michael S. Berliner.
Thursday, October 1, 2009
Cost of the Fundamental Right to Education
An article in the Times of India a couple of days back reminded me of one of Ayn Rand’s striking essays in which she defined the nature of fundamental rights in a free and rational society.
This article, devoted to the cost of the ‘fundamental right to education’ in
However, according to Ayn Rand, the phrase ‘fundamental right to education’ is invalid. Fundamental rights, or individual rights, according to
“A “right” is a moral principle defining and sanctioning a man’s freedom of action in a social context. There is only one fundamental right (all the others are its consequences or corollaries): a man’s right to his own life. Life is a process of self- sustaining and self-generated action; the right to life means the right to engage in self-sustaining and self-generated action-which means: the freedom to take all the actions required by the nature of a rational being for the support, the furtherance, the fulfillment and the enjoyment of his own life. (Such is the meaning of the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.)
The concept of a “right” pertains only to action—specifically, to freedom of action. It means freedom from physical compulsion, coercion or interference by other men.”
In a free society, there is no right to a product, according to her (education is a product). If the people are given the right to any product, it is always at someone’s expense, as every product has to be produced and paid for by someone.
“If some men are entitled by right to the products of the work of others, it means that those others are deprived of rights and condemned to slave labor.”
In the case of the fundamental right to education, there is only one way the government can pay for its whopping costs: taxation (whether direct or indirect). If you are an earning individual in
On the other hand, the right to property, which is a crucial fundamental right in any civilized society, is not a fundamental right in
Click here to read Ayn Rand’s article ‘Man’s Rights’. It is a good opportunity to reflect on some of the fundamental rights that exist (and don’t exist) in our constitution.





